So, Shepherd’s Pie Baked Potato… this one kind of happened by accident because I’d made a whole bunch of mashed potatoes (like, an embarrassing amount), then realized I was completely out of casserole dishes. But there I was, staring at these lovely baked spuds in the fridge, and suddenly thought—what if the best of both worlds? I swear, the first time I tried it, the kitchen sort of looked like a toddler had been let loose. But the end result? Totally worth the mild chaos. My sister, Gemma, still asks if I’ll ‘do the magic potatoes’ whenever she visits.

Why I Keep Coming Back To This Recipe

I make this whenever it’s cold enough for a jumper or everyone’s just grumpy and hungry at the same time. My family absolutely goes mad for these because they’re proper comfort food but also fun to eat—like, who doesn’t love a food that’s sort of both a dinner and a side all in one potatoey shell? Plus, it’s sneaky-good for using up the odd stray carrot or bit of leftover mince in the fridge (and the occasional sad-looking celery stalk, but we don’t speak of that). Honestly, the worst bit was me once burning my fingers trying to scoop out the potatoes too soon. Now I just make a cup of tea and force myself to wait.

Here’s What You’ll Need (Sort of)

4 large baking potatoes (King Edwards are ace, but hey, Maris Pipers will do—Grandma always went with King Edwards though, swearing it ‘soaks up the gravy best’)
About 300g minced lamb (beef works if you’re out of lamb, or mushrooms if you fancy going veggie)
1 small onion, finely chopped (I’ve been known to just use spring onions if that’s what’s left)
1 small carrot, diced
1-2 cloves garlic, minced (I cheat and use the stuff in a jar sometimes—don’t tell Mum)
1 tablespoon tomato paste – I’ve totally subbed passata before, works fine
Handful frozen peas (or skip if you’re not feeling it)
50ml beef stock (give or take, just enough to loosen things up)
A glug of Worcestershire sauce
A sprinkle each of salt, pepper, and dried thyme (or just eyeball it, honestly I do)
Butter and splash of milk for mashing (no shame in adding a bit of cheese too, especially if it's looking a bit dull)
Optional: grated cheddar for topping

Here’s How I Do It (Wobbles Included)

First off, jab your potatoes a few times with a fork. Bake at 200°C (that’s roughly 400°F) for about an hour—you want that jacket crispy. I usually forget to set a timer and just poke them until they feel right; you’ll know.
While your potatoes are getting all soft and fluffy, heat a frying pan over medium. Add the mince; brown it nicely, breaking up lumps. Toss in onion and carrot, cook till they’re a bit soft—maybe 5-7 minutes. Garlic follows (and it will smell like proper dinner at this stage). Tomato paste goes in next; give it a minute. Anything stuck to the pan? Splash in some stock and scrape it up. Add thyme, Worcestershire, peas, and season. Let it bubble away—about 10 minutes is fine. (This is where I usually nick a spoonful ‘to check the seasoning’, but mostly just because I can’t wait.)
Slice off the tops of your baked potatoes (let them cool a sec—trust me, learned the hard way). Scoop out the fluffy insides into a bowl, leaving a shell. Mash with butter, a splash of milk, and any extras you like.
Spoon your mince mixture into each potato shell, piling it high (it’s going to look a bit mountain-like, don’t panic). Dollop the mash on top, fluff it up with a fork, and—if you’re so inclined—scatter some cheddar.
Pop them back in the oven, 10-15 minutes until golden with little crispy edges showing. Occasionally, mine have gone a bit too brown on top, so watch closely near the end!

Little Notes You Might Thank Me For

If you’re worried about the potato shells collapsing, leave a good half-centimeter when you scoop the insides. (I got overambitious once, big mess.)
I actually think they taste even better the day after, but they rarely last that long.
If the top looks a bit pale, flick on the grill for a minute—but do not walk away. Or you’ll be scraping char.

Twists and Experiments (Good, Bad, and Odd)

I tried it once with sweet potatoes—it’s... different. Sweeter, obviously; not sure I’d do it again, but you might love it.
Lentils make a pretty good veggie version actually, especially if you cook them with good stock and a splash of soy for umami.
Once, I added leftover roast chicken—honestly, just made it weird. Wouldn’t bother.
You could try different top cheeses—Red Leicester is ace if you want it super melty.

Equipment (But Don’t Stress)

Baking tray—though a roasting tin works if you’ve lost your tray (as I have—twice).
Sharp knife for opening the potatoes (or just a butter knife with a bit more elbow grease).
Potato masher—I mean, a fork works fine, just takes more effort. Actually, once used a clean mug. Not my finest moment but hey, it worked!

How To Store (If You Have Any Left…)

Technically, you can keep these in the fridge for 2 days in an airtight container. But honestly, in my house, one spare potato is a myth; they vanish by morning. If by some miracle you have leftovers, do let them cool before you stash them, and reheat in the oven if possible—it keeps the skins nicely crisp. Microwave works but—you know, it’s just not the same.

How I Love To Serve Them

I’ll be real, we eat these as the main event with a quick green salad (if anyone protests, I hand them a jar of pickled onions and tell them to get creative). We’ve also snuck them onto a brunch table, because why not? My nephew swears they’re ‘better with ketchup’ (not for me, but I admire his moxy).

‘Don’t Do What I Did’ Pro Tips

Seriously, let the spuds cool a bit before you scoop. The roof of my mouth still remembers.
Don’t go too wild with the stock; soggy potatoes are no one’s friend.
I once rushed mashing the potatoes, left lumps, and got gently roasted by the family. Take the minute, mash it well—it’s worth the arm workout.

Questions People Have Actually Asked Me

Can I use jacket potatoes I made yesterday? Yeh, absolutely! Actually, I think they’re a bit sturdier that way, so go for it.
Do I have to use lamb? Nope! Beef is classic cottage pie; mushrooms or lentils go veggie. I once used turkey mince, wouldn’t rush to repeat it, but it worked in a pinch.
My mash never browns, what am I doing wrong? Try a smidge more butter or a bit of cheese on top, and crank up your oven for that last 5 minutes. Or use this little trick I found on BBC Good Food—they say to use the grill for a minute, which I can vouch for (just don’t wander off!).
Can you freeze them? I’ve done this once or twice—they’re totally edible after freezing, but the potato sometimes goes a tiny bit mealy. If you care about texture, eat fresh. Or see what The Kitchn says about freezing baked potatoes if you want all the specifics.
What’s the best way to reheat? If you’re quick and hungry, microwave’s fine—don’t judge. But oven’s best for crisp skins (about 180°C for 15 mins does it for me).

Oh, and before I forget—if you’re in need of more cozy dinner inspiration, Delish’s baked potato guide is always a giggle and full of good ideas. Just don’t blame me if you end up with a dozen spuds to use up!

Shepherd’s Pie Baked Potato

Why I Keep Coming Back To This Recipe

Here’s What You’ll Need (Sort of)

Here’s How I Do It (Wobbles Included)

Little Notes You Might Thank Me For

Twists and Experiments (Good, Bad, and Odd)

Equipment (But Don’t Stress)

How To Store (If You Have Any Left…)

How I Love To Serve Them

‘Don’t Do What I Did’ Pro Tips

Questions People Have Actually Asked Me

Shepherd’s Pie Baked Potato

Ingredients

Instructions

Approximate Information for One Serving

Nutrition Disclaimers

Did you make this recipe?