Wait—Have You Tried Ina Garten’s Meatloaf Yet?

Okay, so picture this: It’s pouring outside. I mean, proper cats and dogs. I’m looking for comfort food, the kind you can smell from the hallway (or two flights up, honestly), and this Ina Garten’s Meatloaf recipe just sort of calls my name. The first time I made it, I put on Sinatra and ended up with a kitchen splattered in ketchup and onions. As it baked, the whole place suddenly smelled like every happy Sunday dinner rolled into one loaf-shaped miracle. Not to get too dramatic, but it’s now become a bit of an occasion—sometimes an excuse just to use that old bread I don’t have the heart to toss.

Why You’ll Probably Fall in Love With This Meatloaf

I make this when I want something that says, “you worked hard this week, now eat something substantial.” My family legit goes bonkers for it (even my cousin who claims she’s "not a meatloaf person"—she quietly boxed up leftovers my last go-round). It’s simple, nothing too fancy. I think it’s the combo of onions and ketchup; also, the crusty top always gets devoured first—I sometimes wish I could bake just the ends. Oh, and if you’ve ever looked at ground beef and thought, “what now?” this is honestly the only acceptable answer in my book. The cleanup can be a tad annoying (sticky pans!), but you just can’t argue with the results.

What Goes in the Meatloaf (Plus Some Swaps)

2 tablespoon olive oil (or a little butter if that’s what you have—Grandma swore by it but, really, use what’s handy)
2 cups chopped yellow onions (sometimes I use an extra half onion if I’m feeling jazzy...or if they’re looking sad in the veggie drawer)
1 teaspoon salt—give or take, to taste
½ teaspoon black pepper (I go light because my brother’s got issues with pepper, but you do you)
1 teaspoon dried thyme (I’ve been known to swap in Italian seasoning if I’m out—nobody noticed)
⅓ cup Worcestershire sauce (Lea & Perrins is classic, but store brand kind of tastes the same to me—don’t tell Ina!)
¾ cup chicken stock (sometimes use beef if that’s all I’ve got in the cupboard)
1 tablespoon tomato paste (I have used ketchup in a pinch—it ain’t the end of the world)
2.5 lbs ground beef (80/20 is my preference, but I’ve mixed in some pork on wild days)
1 cup fresh breadcrumbs (honestly, dried ones are fine; in fact, I use Ritz cracker crumbs if I’m feeling lazy)
2 large eggs, beaten lightly
½ cup ketchup, for the top (or barbecue sauce if you’re feeling crafty)

So, How Do You Actually Make This?

Preheat your oven to 325°F; no, not 350°F—grab a coffee while it warms up. In a decent-sized pan, heat your olive oil (or butter, if you’re a rebel) over medium, then toss in those onions, salt, pepper, and thyme. Stir it up—don’t walk away! After about ten minutes (or until the onions look soft and kind of translucent), mix in the Worcestershire, tomato paste, and stock. You want it a little saucy, not soupy. Let it cool. I usually pop the pan on the back porch if it’s chilly outside (faster than using the fridge, just watch out for raccoons—ask me later).

Now, dump your ground beef, cooled onion mix, breadcrumbs, and eggs in a big bowl. I use my hands to mush it all together—don’t be shy, just wash up before, yeah? This is actually where I sneak a little taste (I know uncooked eggs aren’t everyone’s thing, so maybe do as I say, not as I do). If it feels dry, add a splash more chicken stock, but don’t go crazy. Too wet and it turns to mush.

Spoon it onto a lined baking sheet—freeform style, like a big football. If you want to use a loaf pan, go for it, but honestly, it kind of just steams the bottom. Slather a hefty layer of ketchup over the top. I don’t measure; just make it look like it’ll form a solid glaze. Into the oven for about 75-80 minutes. Don’t worry if it looks...long. It’ll tighten up as it bakes (mine usually cracks down the middle; it’s character, not a flaw!).

Let it rest for a good ten minutes or more before serving—let it do its thing. Otherwise, you’ll get the "meatloaf crumble" all over your plate. Learned that the hard way.

Notes from Hard-Won Experience

One time I used extra eggs, thinking it’d be fluffier. Nope—came out weird and rubbery. Stick to two.
If you only have dried breadcrumbs, use a bit less or splash in a bit more stock—otherwise you get this odd dry corner thing happening.
Actually, make sure your onions are soft—crunchy onions in a meatloaf are a crime (probably lower than parking tickets, but still).

Meatloaf Experiments and Oddball Variations

So, I once tried using ground turkey to make it “healthier.” It was, well, sad. The flavor vanished and my dog got more leftovers than usual. But I have tossed in chopped mushrooms or even a squirt of sriracha into the glaze if I’m feeling spicy. Sometimes I swap half the beef for pork. Gives it a little extra...what’s the word? Oomph. If you ever sprinkle cheddar in the middle, let me know if it works. It sounded good, but I chickened out at the last minute, so the world may never know.

The Gear You’ll Probably Want (But Maybe Don’t Need)

I say a sheet pan lined with foil is easiest (I used to use a loaf pan, but it always stuck; lesson learned). Got parchment? Even better—makes cleanup easier. If you’re missing a mixing bowl, just grab your biggest pot—it’ll do the job. And if you don’t have a meat thermometer (I lost mine twice now), just cut in and make sure it isn’t pink in the middle. Not rocket science. Oh, and a spatula that won’t bend under pressure is your best pal here.

Storing Leftovers (If You Have ‘Em)

Pop any leftovers in an airtight container, tuck it in the fridge, and you’re golden for 3-4 days. It reheats beautifully—maybe tastes even better the next day, if you ask me. Can you freeze it? Yes, but truth be told, it’s never lasted in my house long enough to even try. The one time I did, I forgot about it for two months and it was just a meatloaf-flavored ice cube. Anyway, fresh is best.

Serving Time: What’s Good with This?

I always do classic mashed potatoes—sometimes with chives when I need to feel fancy. My mom insists on green beans on the side, and I’m not going to argue. If you eat it cold on a sandwich the next day, you’re living right. Once, my uncle dunked slices in gravy, which was weird, but not bad. I also sometimes whip up a little horseradish mayo if I’m feeling sassy.

What I’ve Messed Up: Pro Tips (So You Don’t Have To)

Don’t rush mixing—if you do, you get clumpy meat bits and dry spots. Been there, ate that. Not worth it.
If you cut it before resting, you’ll just have crumbles everywhere (learn from my impatience).
Tried baking it at 375°F to “speed things up.” Came out dry as an old bone—take your time, trust me.

Real-Life FAQs from Friends and Strangers

Can I use ground turkey or chicken?
Eh, technically yes, but I tried it once and it was just a bit, well, disappointing—like expecting fireworks and getting one sad sparkler.

How do I know when it’s cooked?
Great question. Officially, it’s done at 160°F in the middle, but if you don’t have a thermometer (I keep losing mine), just check for clear juices and no pink bits. Worst case, just grab a test slice—nobody’s judging!

I don’t have fresh breadcrumbs—what should I do?
Honestly, crush some crackers, toast up slices of bread and blitz them, or even use panko. Actually, I find it works better if you keep them a bit coarse for texture—fine breadcrumbs can make it dense.

Why does my meatloaf fall apart?
Could be too little binder (eggs, crumbs), or you cut it too soon. Or, just blame your oven and try again. Happens to the best of us.

Any no-fail secret tips?
Don’t let the onion mix be hot when you add it—scrambled egg meatloaf is...not tasty. And don’t over-mix. Actually, that’s key—just enough to bring it together but not so much it’s paste.

So there it is—Ina Garten’s Meatloaf, warts, wisdom, wildcards, and all. Now go mess up your kitchen in the best way possible.

Ina Garten’s Meatloaf Recipe: My Chatty, Cozy Guide

Wait—Have You Tried Ina Garten’s Meatloaf Yet?

Why You’ll Probably Fall in Love With This Meatloaf

What Goes in the Meatloaf (Plus Some Swaps)

So, How Do You Actually Make This?

Notes from Hard-Won Experience

Meatloaf Experiments and Oddball Variations

The Gear You’ll Probably Want (But Maybe Don’t Need)

Storing Leftovers (If You Have ‘Em)

Serving Time: What’s Good with This?

What I’ve Messed Up: Pro Tips (So You Don’t Have To)

Real-Life FAQs from Friends and Strangers

Ina Garten’s Meatloaf

Ingredients

Instructions

Approximate Information for One Serving

Nutrition Disclaimers

Did you make this recipe?