Have You Ever Tried Baking Magic Into a Cupcake?

I still remember the first time I attempted these Harry Potter Butterbeer Cupcakes. I was probably running on too little sleep, and my kitchen was a disaster (seriously, butterscotch everywhere — even in my hair). Anyway, my niece is a massive Potterhead and basically demanded "something from Hogsmeade" for her birthday a few years ago. So of course, I said yes, then frantically googled for ideas over my second cup of tea. These cupcakes are what I landed on. They’re my go-to ever since — though if I had a Slytherin in my house, I’d probably have to hide them somewhere.

Why I Keep Coming Back to This Recipe

I make these whenever someone mentions a movie marathon, or just when the English weather gets that perfect, moody drizzle (which, let's be honest, happens a lot here). My family goes bonkers for the soft, butterscotch-y sponge — especially my mum, who claims she’s too grown-up for Harry Potter but then sneaks two when no one’s watching. Oh, and there was that one time the butterscotch sauce boiled over and I had a mini kitchen meltdown, so don't do what I did — keep a tight eye on it.

You've Got to Grab These Ingredients...

200g (about 1 ⅔ cups) plain flour (all-purpose works; I sometimes even use half-and-half with whole wheat if that's all I've got)
1 ¼ teaspoon baking powder
A modest pinch of salt
120g (½ cup plus a smidge) unsalted butter, room temp (honestly, I’ve used salted butter in a pinch, just skip the extra salt if you do!)
150g (roughly ¾ cup) brown sugar — light or dark, it doesn't make a huge difference
2 large eggs (I once used 3 medium-sized ones and nothing bad happened)
60ml (¼ cup) cream soda (yes, the fizzy stuff — supermarket own-brand is fine, though my Grandma always swears by Barritt's. I can't taste the difference honestly.)
2 teaspoon vanilla extract
60ml (¼ cup) whole milk
Butterscotch sauce: 100g (about ½ cup) light brown sugar, 50g (¼ cup) unsalted butter, 60ml (¼ cup) cream, dash of vanilla
(Or just buy a bottle, no shame here. I sometimes do when I can't be bothered!)
Butterbeer frosting: 125g (½ cup plus a spoonful) softened butter, 250g (2 cups) icing sugar, 2-3 tablespoon butterscotch sauce, 2 tablespoon cream soda, pinch of salt
Sparkly sugar or gold sprinkles for decoration, if you want to get a bit fancy

So Here’s How I Tend to Fumble My Way Through

Preheat your oven to 175 C / 350 F. Line a muffin tin with paper cases — I like the stripy ones, but the plain white ones are honestly just as decent.
Mix up your flour, baking powder, and salt in a bowl. I don't bother sifting unless I'm really trying to impress someone.
In a separate (and ideally larger) bowl, beat together the butter and brown sugar until it's fluffy and lighter in color — a hand mixer is helpful, but I’ve done it with a spatula on arm day, and survived.
Crack in the eggs, one at a time, mixing just enough. Don’t panic if mixture looks a bit odd here, it’ll smooth out soon. (This is where I usually sneak a little taste; raw eggs be damned).
Stir in the vanilla, cream soda, and milk. Again — it’s going to look a bit runny or even separated, but once you add the dry mix, it comes together. I promise.
Chuck in your dry ingredients in two goes, folding gently. Don’t overmix, or you’ll get weird dense cupcakes and blame me.
Scoop the batter into your cupcake cases — fill them about ⅔ full. A heaping tablespoon does the trick (I always seem to overdo the first few and then run short at the end, so keep an eye, mate).
Bake 18-22 minutes, or until the tops spring back with a gentle poke. Cool them in the tray for a bit, then move to a rack. (Or the windowsill if you want to be like the Weasleys.)
Meanwhile, make your butterscotch sauce: Melt butter and brown sugar in a little pot, pour in the cream, cook a few mins till thick, then add vanilla. Don’t wander off to check your phone here, it bubbles up fast.
Frosting time: Beat the butter until creamy, then beat in the icing sugar, butterscotch, cream soda, and salt. Add more or less sugar depending how sweet you like it. Probably best to just taste as you go. (No judgment. I do.)
Once cupcakes are cool, pipe or slap on the frosting. Drizzle with extra butterscotch and go wild with sprinkles. I sometimes stuff a cupcake with sauce if I’m feeling like a wizard. Or just lazy, and use a knife to poke a hole.

Stuff I've Learned (Sometimes the Hard Way)

The butterscotch sauce thickens as it cools — if you want it runnier, use it quick.
Don’t let the cream soda sit open too long or it fizzes flat (I once poured in a can that had been out all day and it did...not taste magical).
Cupcakes might dome a bit unevenly; I actually like it. More nooks for sauce.

Experiments in Cupcake Alchemy (aka Variations That Mostly Worked)

Tried swapping half the cream soda for root beer once — kind of peculiar, but not tragic. Wouldn't call it Butterbeer, but it's its own thing.
Added a pinch of cinnamon once — subtle, quite nice actually. On second thought, nutmeg overwhelmed them a bit, so I wouldn’t do that again. Unless you really love nutmeg?
They’re decent with vegan butter and oat milk, though the icing was softer (had to chill it in the fridge for 10 mins).

Baking Tools — Or "What If I Don’t Own That?"

Having a mixer helps, but if you haven’t got one, your trusty wooden spoon plus a bit of elbow grease does fine. Icing bags are great, but in a pinch, a zip-top bag with the corner snipped works. And hey, if all else fails, back of the spoon for swirling on the frosting can look pretty charming (and a bit retro), trust me.

How To Store (If They Even Last That Long)

Pop these in an airtight box at room temp for up to two days, or in the fridge if it’s hot out. They get a touch firmer after a night in the fridge, which some folks (ahem, me) quite like with a morning coffee. Freezer? Yeah, you can chuck them in there—without frosting, for up to 2 months—but honestly, in my house, they’re gone by dawn.

Serving Butterbeer Cupcakes Like a True Potterhead

We like them piled onto a mismatched cake stand (because who actually has matching plates? Not me). I sometimes drizzle a bit of extra sauce right as we eat them (messy but worth it), and if there’s a Harry Potter scarf around, a little cupcake photo shoot is basically required. Once even paired them with homemade butterbeer drinks — highly recommend for committing fully to the theme!

Stuff I’ve Messed Up (Pro Tips Learned the Hard Way)

Don’t skimp on creaming the butter and sugar. I tried rushing once and ended up with cupcakes as heavy as a Dursley’s suitcase.
If you try to frost before the cakes are totally cool, it slides right off. Been there. Now I prop open the back door to cool things down faster, even if the cat escapes.
Seriously — just taste the sauce before you start drizzling everywhere. Forgetting the salt once made it all a bit flat.

FAQ — Actual Questions from Muggles (and a Few Wizards)

Can I make these ahead?
Yep! They actually taste pretty fab the next day. Just keep ’em in a sealed box. But, on warm days, frosting gets a bit melty, so maybe stick in the fridge?
What if I can’t find cream soda?
Good question! Ginger ale works too, though it’s not quite the same. Or try ordering Barritt's Cream Soda online — but don't stress, any sweet, vanilla-ish soda will do in a pinch.
Is there a gluten-free version?
I’ve swapped in a solid GF all-purpose blend and had decent results. The texture is slightly different, a bit crumbly, but not bad at all.
Help, my frosting is runny!
Throw it in the fridge for ten mins and give it another whip. Or just embrace the drippy look (I sometimes do). It's frosting, not rocket science!
Which house do these best suit?
Ha! All of them — even Slytherin, if you don't mind a bit of sparkle with your ambition.

Oh, and speaking of sparkle, if you love magical recipes, check out this version from Delish — their tips on piping are surprisingly down-to-earth.

So there you go. Butterbeer Cupcakes that’ll make you feel like you’re tucked away in The Three Broomsticks, even if it’s just your poky kitchen. And if you end up licking the bowl clean, well — you’re in good company.

Harry Potter Butterbeer Cupcakes: A Magical Recipe Guide

Have You Ever Tried Baking Magic Into a Cupcake?

Why I Keep Coming Back to This Recipe

You've Got to Grab These Ingredients...

So Here’s How I Tend to Fumble My Way Through

Stuff I've Learned (Sometimes the Hard Way)

Experiments in Cupcake Alchemy (aka Variations That Mostly Worked)

Baking Tools — Or "What If I Don’t Own That?"

How To Store (If They Even Last That Long)

Serving Butterbeer Cupcakes Like a True Potterhead

Stuff I’ve Messed Up (Pro Tips Learned the Hard Way)

FAQ — Actual Questions from Muggles (and a Few Wizards)

Harry Potter Butterbeer Cupcakes

Ingredients

Instructions

Approximate Information for One Serving

Nutrition Disclaimers

Did you make this recipe?