Let Me Tell You About This Pie—And My Aversion To Holiday Predictability

So, first things first—I love pie. I mean, who doesn't, right? But traditional holiday bakes? Meh. Been there, ate that. One fall, I stumbled onto the combo of pears and cranberries at a roadside farm stand (you know those tables with the hand-painted signs and maybe a few overpriced apples?) and thought, what if I threw those together in a pie? Total hit at my sister's place, and even Uncle Bill, who usually just wants 'plain old apple,' asked for seconds. Not to brag, but it's now sorta my rustic claim to fame—my Cranberry Pear Pie. Occasionally ends up a little lopsided, but hey, life’s short. Also, fun fact: tried using a pie bird once and it toppled over mid-bake—still delicious.

Why I Keep Making This—And Maybe You Will Too

I make this pie every year right around when the first real cold snap hits. My family practically circles like hungry gulls (sorry, y'all!) when they see the cranberries come out. It's tart and sweet at the same time, which is basically all I'm after, especially when regular fruit pies get too sugary for my taste. Oh, and bonus—it covers up for a crust that's not perfectly rolled. If I’m being totally honest, I've mucked up the lattice a dozen times and nobody's cared. Also, this fills the house with a smell that makes even the cat wander in from wherever he’s loafing.

Here's What You'll Need—But Go With Your Gut (and Pantry)

2 cups fresh or frozen cranberries (I use frozen when I forgot to prep—a life-saver!)
3 medium ripe pears, peeled and sliced—not too fussy about the variety, but Bartlett’s cool. My gran swears by Bosc, though, but honestly, any will do.
1 cup sugar (sometimes I sneak in half brown sugar if I want it a bit richer)
2 tablespoons cornstarch OR 3 tablespoons flour—whichever you grab first
1 tablespoon lemon juice—squeeze it fresh if you’ve got a lemon, but bottled stuff works fine in a pinch
½ teaspoon ground cinnamon
¼ teaspoon ground ginger (totally skip if you’re not a ginger person—you do you!)
Pinch of salt
2 tablespoons butter, cut in bits
1 double crust pie pastry (store-bought’s fine, but my favorite homemade is this one; sometimes I just use puff pastry because... time)
1 egg, lightly beaten (optional—just to brush on top… helps that shine)
Coarse sugar for sprinkling—if you want those sparkly bits on top

Okay, Here's How You Throw It Together

Prep the fruit: Mix your (thawed if frozen) cranberries and pears in a big bowl. I go ahead and toss in the sugar, cornstarch (or flour), lemon juice, cinnamon, ginger, and salt. Give it a good mix—don’t stress if it looks like a jumble at this stage; the flavors meld in the oven. Honestly, this is the part where I usually eat a few cranberries, raw. Regrets, sometimes.
Pastry time: Roll out your bottom crust and fit it into a 9-inch pie dish (or something close; nobody's policing this). Trim off the overhang, or just sort of fold it in if you're not feeling precise. Preheat oven to 400°F (about 200°C), unless you're like me and constantly forget and have to do it halfway through.
Fill 'er up: Pour the fruit mixture into your crust. Dot with those little bits of butter—scatter them like confetti. It looks odd, but trust me.
Top it off: Lay on the top crust; you can go classic, do a wonky lattice (my specialty), or just cut shapes out and patch it together. Don't fuss too much. Seal the edges as best you can (I never get a perfect crimp) and cut a few slits for steam escape—or forget, and the pie vents itself; not dramatic.
Egg wash + sugar: If you want, brush the top with beaten egg and sprinkle sugar. Or skip it. Pie will still be pie.
Bake: Place on a baking sheet, because let's be real, the filling always bubbles out (and I despise scrubbing the oven). Bake 25 minutes, then drop the temp to 350°F (175°C) and bake 30 more, till golden and bubbly. If the crust starts looking like it spent spring break at the beach, tent with foil.
Cool-ish: Let it rest for a good hour. I know, it smells AMAZING and people hover. But hot filling will go everywhere if you slice too soon—I've tried, regretted, and gone back to scraping pie off the counter.

Some Notes You'll Want to Read (Probably)

Pear size matters! Too thin, and they just disappear. Too thick, they'll fight you when slicing.
I've tried this with canned pears. Not the same. The filling gets mushy. Fresh is best—second thought, frozen ones can work, but thaw and pat them dry.
If you forget the lemon juice (I've spaced out more than once), the filling is just a tad too sweet. I wouldn’t skip it unless you’re in a real pickle.

Some Pie Curveballs (a.k.a Variations I’ve Attempted)

Once, I added a handful of chopped walnuts for crunch. Nice, but turned out a bit odd for my taste.
Subbed half the cranberries with chopped, dried apricots—inspired by an apple pie adaptation I saw. Suprisingly tasty (try it?)
Tried a crumble topping once instead of pie crust—more like a crisp, but pretty solid if you love streusel.
Mistake: tried adding orange zest. Made it taste like marmalade pie. My folks weren't fans; lesson learned.

Let’s Talk Equipment (But Don't Panic if You're Missing Stuff)

Pie dish—any standard 9-inch works. Some day I'll remember not to use my too-small tart tin, but oh well.
Rolling pin—I've used a wine bottle in a pinch. Works just fine, just watch for the label glue (seriously!)
Parchment-lined baking sheet to catch drips; but old foil works too, or just scrub the oven later…I’ve been there.

About Storing This Pie (If There's Any Left, That Is)

It keeps at room temp for, honestly, about a day (it’s usually gone by breakfast). But if you somehow have leftovers, just cover and refrigerate—I like it cold, but apparently that’s weird. Freezes alright too, though once it picked up a bit of odd freezer taste after a couple months. Best to eat it sooner rather than treat it like a time capsule dessert.

How We Serve It (the Family Way)

This is practically begging for a scoop of vanilla ice cream. Or, if you’re feeling fancy, a dollop of whipped cream with a little cinnamon sprinkled right on top—my niece always tries to lick it off and leave the pie itself, cheeky thing. Sometimes, we re-heat slices in a low oven just until warm and serve with a cup of strong tea (bonus points if you have a cozy jumper on).

A Few Pro Tips From My Happily Imperfect Kitchen

If your fruit filling seems super soupy before baking, scoop out some juice—once I ignored this, and ended up with a pie tsunami on my cutting board.
Chill your pastry before rolling. I once skipped this step thinking I’d save time and ended up patching holes for ages; wasn't worth it.
The bottom crust gets crisper if you start the pie on the lower oven rack, but, real talk, I've also just popped it in the middle and lived to tell the tale.

Pie FAQs From The Folks Who Keep Me Honest

Can I use just pears, no cranberries?: For sure, but it’ll be sweet. Maybe add a bit of lemon zest to punch it up (or sneak in a few frozen berries from the back of the freezer).
How do I keep the crust from getting soggy?: Chill the dough, bake on the lower rack, and if you’re feeling fancy, sprinkle a little flour or crushed cookies in first. Honestly, sometimes it still happens and I call it ‘rustic.’
Can I make it gluten free?: Yep! Use your go-to gluten-free pie crust, and double check your thickener. Bob’s Red Mill has a good blend (they don't pay me to say this).
Can I prep it ahead?: I’d prep the filling and crust the night before and keep separate. Actually, on second thought, I tried assembling too far ahead once and the crust got gummy—not my finest hour.
You sure about the ginger?: Ha! I use it for a hint of warmth. But if you’re a ginger-skeptic, it’s totally fine to skip.

So, that’s my Cranberry Pear Pie. It’s a bit sweet, a bit tart, a little rough around the edges—so basically, like most of my favorite things. Oh, almost forgot—if you have anything left (rare!), it makes a pretty ace breakfast. Not health food, but hey, you only live once. If you give it a try, send a photo my way? Or better yet, just eat another slice and call it even.

Cranberry Pear Pie: My Favorite Cozy Pie Recipe Ever

Let Me Tell You About This Pie—And My Aversion To Holiday Predictability

Why I Keep Making This—And Maybe You Will Too

Here's What You'll Need—But Go With Your Gut (and Pantry)

Okay, Here's How You Throw It Together

Some Notes You'll Want to Read (Probably)

Some Pie Curveballs (a.k.a Variations I’ve Attempted)

Let’s Talk Equipment (But Don't Panic if You're Missing Stuff)

About Storing This Pie (If There's Any Left, That Is)

How We Serve It (the Family Way)

A Few Pro Tips From My Happily Imperfect Kitchen

Pie FAQs From The Folks Who Keep Me Honest

Cranberry Pear Pie

Ingredients

Instructions

Approximate Information for One Serving

Nutrition Disclaimers

Did you make this recipe?