So, Chicken Enchilada Casserole – Here’s the Deal

I can’t remember exactly when I first threw together this Chicken Enchilada Casserole – probably a Tuesday when I realized I’d forgotten to defrost half the ingredients for dinner. You know those days when you’re eyeing the stack of tortillas, a can of something in the pantry, and leftover rotisserie Chicken that somehow didn’t get inhaled by the kids? That’s basically how this started for me. And honestly, it’s become my go-to when I want crowd-pleaser flavors but there’s no energy (or interest) in rolling up individual enchiladas. It’s the casserole equivalent of a bear hug.

Why I Keep Making This Over and Over

I make this for family visits because apparently it reminds my dad of something he had in New Mexico but – in his words – 'less spicy and more cheesy (and please tell me next time it’ll be bigger)'. My family goes kind of bonkers for the crispy cheese corners. Also, you can make it days in advance if you’re feeling ambitious, or just play pantry clean-out and nobody will ever know. Sometimes, honestly, I throw it together after a long day when even chopping onions feels too ambitious. Oh, and if you ever get annoyed with having to roll up enchiladas, trust me, this is your answer – just layer and move on.

Gather What You’ve Got – The Ingredients

2 to 3 cups cooked chicken, shredded (I usually use rotisserie – leftover grilled chicken works, and I’ve 100% thrown in turkey at Thanksgiving with zero complaints)
10-12 small corn tortillas (sometimes I’ll tear up flour tortillas if that’s all we have, though some folks might gasp)
1 can (15 oz) red enchilada sauce (my gran always swore by Las Palmas but frankly, store brand works fine; or use green sauce if you’re feeling wild)
1 cup sour cream (or Greek yogurt – less creamy but still good)
2 cups shredded cheese (Cheddar, Monterey Jack, or whatever’s hanging out in your fridge waiting to be used)
½ cup chopped onion (optional; sometimes I skip chopping and just use a big pinch of onion powder)
1 small can black beans, drained and rinsed (optional – honestly, whatever bean you like will work in a pinch)
½ teaspoon cumin (or taco seasoning if you’re lazy like me sometimes)
Salt and pepper to taste
Chopped fresh cilantro or green onions for topping (look, I forget these half the time and no one complains)

Here’s How I Throw It Together

Preheat your oven to 375°F (190°C). No need for precision – I’ve baked at 350° and 400° and everything turned out edible.
In a big ol' bowl, mix chicken, about half the enchilada sauce, sour cream, half your cheese, onions, beans, and cumin. This is where I usually sneak a taste and add salt or more seasoning if it feels bland (sometimes it does – no shame in that).
Grab a medium baking dish (8x11 or similar; honestly, I’ve made this in a round dish and it still came out great). Drizzle just a bit of the leftover sauce to prevent sticking. Layer half the tortillas along the bottom. Tear them to fit if you’re not into fancy stuff.
Spoon half the chicken mixture over the tortillas. Add a bit more cheese if you’re feeling generous. Repeat with the rest of the tortillas, sauce, chicken mixture, and finish with a mountain (yes, mountain) of cheese on top.
Cover lightly with foil (otherwise the cheese gets a bit too brown – unless you’re into that, then live your life).
Bake about 25 minutes, then remove foil and bake another 10-15 until it’s bubbly and golden at the edges. Sometimes I broil for the last two minutes if I want drama. Don’t worry if it looks weird at this stage – it always does! Let it rest for at least 10 mins before slicing or it’ll just ooze everywhere.

Notes I’ve Learned the Hard Way

If you make it too saucy, yes, it’s delicious but it’ll fall apart on your plate (maybe you don’t mind, but my kids do).
I’ve used day-old tortillas that were honestly close to cardboard – the casserole still worked! So don’t fuss too much about perfect freshness.
Don’t skip the resting. I used to, and then my casserole turned into a lava flow. Actually, letting it sit for like 20 mins gives great slices.

Times I’ve Gone Off Script (and What Happened)

I once put frozen corn in with the chicken – winner.
Tried with green enchilada sauce; folks either loved it or wouldn’t stop asking what was different.
Once tried with BBQ sauce by accident (don’t recommend; tasted like confused nachos).
Added spinach for "health" points (my family saw right through it, but it tasted fine to me).

Equipment-ish (Don’t Sweat It)

You technically want a baking dish. But I’ve used an old cast iron skillet, even a metal cake tin once. Results are more ‘rustic’ but totally fine.
Mixing bowl – your biggest, or just use the baking dish itself if you’re not into extra washing.

Stashing Leftovers (or Not)

If by some miracle you have leftovers, put them in a container and stash in the fridge for 2-3 days. It reheats well in the microwave (sometimes better than the first day, just saying!) Though, honestly, in my house it never lasts more than a day – probably because someone keeps nabbing seconds for "taste testing".

How I Like to Serve It (But You Do You)

Okay, so my favorite way is with a big scoop of guac and a squeeze of lime. If I’m feeling fancy I’ll add shredded lettuce and diced tomatoes (my mom calls this ‘enchilada salad’ and I can’t say she’s wrong). My kids always ask for corn chips on the side, probably so they can scoop instead of fork – and honestly, who can blame them?

Lessons I’ve Picked Up (Usually the Hard Way)

Don’t rush the cheese melting. I tried cranking the oven up to hurry along and, welp, black cheese. Just… don’t.
Once I forgot to cover with foil – edges turned out okay but the middle was dry. So, cover, then remove the foil partway through. Works every time (well, except for once when I used the wrong rack, but that’s another story).

FAQ: Actual Things Folks Have Asked Me

Can I make this ahead? Yup, you can assemble it a day early (just don’t bake), keep it in the fridge, and bake before serving. Sometimes I think it’s even better the next day.
Can I freeze it? Definitely; bake it first and freeze leftovers, or freeze unbaked and add 10-15 mins extra bake time. Just don’t expect that fresh-out-of-the-oven crispiness, but flavor-wise it holds up.
My tortillas are weirdly chewy/hard. Why? That happens to me when I use too little sauce or overbake. Next time, drown the bottom layer in extra sauce (just a splash).
Can I make it veggie? Oh yeah – just skip chicken, use more beans, or try roasted zucchini. I did once try tofu but, um, not for me – you might love it though!
Do I need to let it rest before serving? Yes, unless you want more of a ‘chicken enchilada soup’ situation on your plate. It’s your call.
Cheese recommendations? I say: whatever melts and makes you happy. Pepper Jack if you like a little kick, or go totally wild with smoked cheese if you want to impress someone.

And just as a total aside (because you don’t get enough random trivia with recipes): once, when I couldn’t find a can opener for the enchilada sauce, I used the heel of a bread knife. I wouldn’t recommend it but, hey, desperate times call for creative measures. So, however you get your casserole going, I hope it fills your table with laughter and lots of happy forks. Let me know how it goes (unless you use BBQ sauce, then… maybe don’t tell me).

Chicken Enchilada Casserole Recipe That’s Crazy Easy

So, Chicken Enchilada Casserole – Here’s the Deal

Why I Keep Making This Over and Over

Gather What You’ve Got – The Ingredients

Here’s How I Throw It Together

Notes I’ve Learned the Hard Way

Times I’ve Gone Off Script (and What Happened)

Equipment-ish (Don’t Sweat It)

Stashing Leftovers (or Not)

How I Like to Serve It (But You Do You)

Lessons I’ve Picked Up (Usually the Hard Way)

FAQ: Actual Things Folks Have Asked Me

Chicken Enchilada Casserole

Ingredients

Instructions

Approximate Information for One Serving

Nutrition Disclaimers

Did you make this recipe?